Global Sensemaking

Tools for Dialogue and Deliberation on Wicked Problems

Twain's Comments

Comment Wall (17 comments)

At 23:56 on November 2, 2008, Giorgio Bertini said…
Nice to see you here. How are you, how do you feel, I haven't heard from you. I have sent you an invite to my new Twine - Accountability - very much related to what you shared with me here. Best wishes to you my friend. Giorgio
At 0:53 on November 3, 2008, Giorgio Bertini said…
Nice to hear from you again, even if with some sad news. Thanks for those ideas and links. I will study them.
At 21:42 on November 4, 2008, Mark Szpakowski said…
Thanks for the great set of resources, Twain!

Re economic policy and financial crisis, I think (along with the Oct 18-24 New Scientist special issue on The Folly of Growth: How to stop the economy killing the planet) that it's essential to address the money-as-debt continuous-growth ponzi scheme at the heart of current economic theory (I am right there, am I not? Am I missing something?). Or, perhaps equivalently, some repressor agents need to be added to an otherwise positive-feedback only picture.

If this is such a critical point, then just identifying it, and framing discourse on it within this frame (of money-as-debt being key viewpoint needing to be turned around) would seem to be most relevant sense-making, would it not?

The next step would be to frame a new theory. My thinking there is along the lines of
- wealth as number of forward days of survival (from Bucky Fuller);
- wealth as resources X wisdom (so rsrcs X wisdom = forward days)

(wisdom as ability to apply resources non-destructively over time, with minimum time span probably being at least two generarations)

That resourcesXwisdom creates the cornucopia/basket against which a currency is based (as in Lietaer's terra currency).

But question is: how do you measure wisdom? One thought is that having a "wealth steward" position/function or person might help (this must meet politics, or have power over it, else it's theoretical). The role of that wealth steward is to join Heaven and Earth (in taoist sense).

Achieving something like this would in itself be a singularity!
At 16:36 on November 6, 2008, Mark Szpakowski said…
Hi Twain, I did miss those comments (lack of comment-tracking is a Twine anti-pattern), and added one.

I came across the Google 10^100 challenge too late - I have a perhaps overly large project I might have offered. I did see your greenspot proposal just recently: using Google Earth as an interface to ourselves is both a winner for Google and an enabler for ourselves.

Re impacting the bottom line: that's a fulcrum point. Re-framing the bottom line meme (as in triple bottom line etc) is I think a necessary part of making systemic change. Currently bottom line is a one-dimensional symbol (maximize shareholder value) with no intrinsic brakes.

Your approach of looking at how to evaluate demand is interesting, and seems to acknowledge demand as a social construct, which could include the current reality of demand also being very much a generated product.

I'll take a further look at the greenspot submission - you have others as well?

At 2:21 on November 9, 2008, Giorgio Bertini said…
Hi Twain,

Thanks for the "Man versus Machine" paper. A very interesting one. I have also posted some others at Twine on error in models and the financial crisis. Over emphasis in modelling was something like a proxy of regulation, certainly some of the causes. Have a look at this

The financial crisis has morphed into a full fledge economic crisis, with the first still going on, the second will require far more complex policies to be tackled, with serious social and political consequences.

I am now interested on research about the real economy causes of the financial crisis, as a way to understand needed strategic changes. The easy money mistake, Greenspan responsability, etc are all true, but all those mistakes are related to political economy requirements of those moments. They do not come to life from nothing. Even stabilizing the financial system, the root real economy causes will remain. That is a far more complex challenge.

With a firm belief that the market is the solution, any big change in policy requieres a cultural (social and political) new paradigm, that goes beyond keynesianism or postkeynesianism. Is not enough with stimulus policies, just because they can even agravate the structural deficiencies. Structural changes are always paradigmatic in terms of genesis. Have a look to some links.

Besides all these serious matters, The Twinery is going healthy, the First Congress is being thinking carefully. We miss your comments. Regards and best wishes.
At 3:54 on November 12, 2008, lynn said…
hey twain
giorgio just sent me an invite here!
At 20:27 on November 12, 2008, David Price said…

Thanks for the feedback on the Essence logo—and a belated welcome to the group. It's great to have you here.

At 0:51 on November 15, 2008, rpfiii said…
here kitty, kitty, kitty

At 2:11 on November 15, 2008, lynn said…
smart move - thx

At 2:35 on November 15, 2008, lynn said…
At 2:41 on November 15, 2008, lynn said…
chess so young! wow

i'm impressed.

alice has another meaning that fintsrigh in with alice/w.. carnigie mellon created a programming language called alice for vr,,,

alice/w is vr iwithout a doubt..

grace slick fits right in :)
At 15:44 on November 15, 2008, rpfiii said…
Isn't that the Alice program you sent me to for my girls?

I couldn't get them to try it--"programming's not cool, dad" they said!
At 16:42 on November 15, 2008, lynn said…
randy paush from cmu that was in charge of all the vr past away. he developed the entire vr program there. if you haven't already, you should watch his last lecture. to say it's incredible is an understatement.

i didn't know about sophie... i'll take a look.
At 16:43 on November 15, 2008, lynn said…
forgot the link to the lecture:
At 16:51 on November 15, 2008, rpfiii said…
re #2, I'll be happy if they just support me...
At 17:00 on November 15, 2008, rpfiii said…
At 17:55 on June 9, 2009, Lynne Johnson said…

As someone born in the year of the white metal tiger, your picture of course got my attention. Tell me, if you will, about the tiger, and your perspective on dialogue o wicked problems. What I really wanted to use as my pix was a short poem I once wrote, but alas, didn't know how to do that.


You need to be a member of Global Sensemaking to add comments!

Join Global Sensemaking




  • Add Videos
  • View All


  • Add Photos
  • View All



© 2021   Created by David Price.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service